A Meta-analysis on the (Quasi)Experimental Studies of Critical Thinking in Second Language Education in Iran

Document Type : Review - analytic article

Authors
1 University of Isfahan
2 University of Western Macedonia
Abstract
Critical Thinking (CT) which has been defined as the employment of cognitive skills or strategies for obtaining sound conclusions (Halpern, 2013) has been the subject of different Second Language (L2) studies at national and international levels. The aim of the present study was to provide a meta-analysis on the (quasi) experimental studies of critical thinking in second language education in Iran. To this end, from a total of 168 studies published between 2011 and 2020, 24 studies were selected based on the inclusion-exclusion criteria. The included studies were coded to calculate the mean effect size of the studies. The results show that 1) L2 teaching was positively effective for the CT development in Iran; 2) the most beneficial aspects of L2 teaching on CT promotion were related to teaching L2 speaking and L2 rhetorical strategies; 3) concerning L2 proficiency level, L2 instruction was most advantageous for advanced students’ CT developments; 4) regarding the age groups, L2 teaching contributed the most growth in CT levels for learners in the age group of 10-14 years, and 5) L2 teaching was most effective for the undergraduate students compared to other educational levels. The findings can be beneficial for pursuing the next moves in L2 research, education, and planning educational policies in Iran.

Keywords

Subjects


7. منابع
• توکل, & لاریجانی. (2016). مطالعه اهداف آموزش و پرورش در تحصیل سواد توسعه ای دانش آموزان و امکانات آی سی تی در تحقق آن. مجله جهانی رسانه-نسخه فارسی, 11(2).‎
References
• Abrami, P. C., Bernard, R. M., Borokhovski, E., Wade, A., Surkes, M. A., Tamim, R., & Zhang, D. (2008). Instructional interventions affecting critical thinking skills and dispositions: A stage 1 meta-analysis. Review of educational research, 78(4), 1102-1134.
• Adibnia, F., & Akbari Chermahini, S. (2020). Comparison of Cognitive Inhibition in Monolingual and Bilingual Students. Language Related Research, 11(4), 1-23.
• Alexander, P. A. (2014). Thinking critically and analytically about critical-analytic thinking: An introduction. Educational Psychology Review, 26(4), 469-476.
• Allen, M., Berkowitz, S., Hunt, S., & Louden, A. (1999). A meta‐analysis of the impact of forensics and communication education on critical thinking. Communication Education, 48(1), 18-30.
• Angeli, C., & Valanides, N. (2009). Instructional effects on critical thinking: Performance on ill-defined issues. Learning and Instruction, 19(4), 322-334.
• AsgharHeidari, F. (2014). The Impact of Media Analysis on the Development of Critical Thinking and Reading Comprehension Skills of the EFL Learners [Master's Thesis, University of Guilan]. Retrieved from (2021, Novamber 20):
https://ganj.irandoc.ac.ir/viewer/f413c2be8cd5c055ec8277effcbd6635?sample=1
• Atkinson, D. (1997). A critical approach to critical thinking in TESOL. TESOL quarterly, 31(1), 71-94.
• Bakhshipour khodaie, F. (2012). A Study on the Relationship between Iranian EFL University Students' Critical Thinking and their Reading Comprehension Skill [Master's Thesis, Arak University]. Retrieved from (2021, Novamber 20):
https://ganj.irandoc.ac.ir/viewer/e53f343fe501cd16626380558d93966e?sample=1
• Bangert-Drowns, R. L., & Bankert, E. (1990). Meta-Analysis of Effects of Explicit Instruction for Critical Thinking. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association (Boston, MA, April 16-20, 1990). Retrieved from (2020, September 11):
https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED328614.pdf
• Benesch, S. (1999). Thinking critically, thinking dialogically. Tesol Quarterly, 33(3), 573-580.
• Bosch, G. (2018). Train PhD students to be thinkers not just specialists. Nature, 554(7690), 277-278.
• Butcher, K. R., Runburg, M., & Altizer, R. (2021). Dino lab: Designing and developing an educational game for critical thinking. In Research Anthology on Developing Critical Thinking Skills in Students (pp. 395-428). IGI Global.
• Calma, A., & Davies, M. (2020). Critical thinking in business education: current outlook and future prospects. Studies in Higher Education, 1-17.
• Cosgrove, D. R. (2013). Improving teaching and learning of critical thinking across the curriculum at a large research university: An empirical study using qualitative methods [Doctoral dissertation, University of Cambridge].
• Danvers, E. (2021). Prevent/Ing critical thinking? The pedagogical impacts of Prevent in UK higher education. Teaching in Higher Education, 1-16.
• Davidson, B. W. (1998). Comments on Dwight Atkinson's" A critical approach to critical thinking in TESOL": A case for critical thinking in the English language classroom. TESOL quarterly, 32(1), 119-123.
• Dehghani, M., Pakmehr, H., & Malekzadeh, A. (2011). Relationship between students’ critical thinking and self-efficacy beliefs in Ferdowsi University of Mashhad, Iran. Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences, 15, 2952-2955.
• Dekker, T. J. (2020). Teaching critical thinking through engagement with multiplicity. Thinking Skills and Creativity, 37, 100701.
• Ennis, R. H. (1962). A concept of critical thinking. Harvard educational review, 32(1), 81–111.
• Etemadfar, P., Soozandehfar, S. M. A., & Namaziandost, E. (2020). An account of EFL learners’ listening comprehension and critical thinking in the flipped classroom model. Cogent Education, 7(1), 1835150.
• Fischer, S. C., & Spiker, V. A. (2000). A framework for critical thinking research and training. Report prepared for the US Army Research Institute.
• Halpern, D. F. (2013). Thought and knowledge: An introduction to critical thinking. Psychology Press.
• Halpern, D. F. (2014). Critical thinking across the curriculum: A brief edition of thought & knowledge. Routledge.
• Heydari, M. (2011). The Relationship between Iranian EFL Students’ Reading Comprehension Micro-skills and Critical Thinking Skills [Master's Thesis, Shahid Rajaee Teacher Training University]. Retrieved from:
https://ganj.irandoc.ac.ir/viewer/e6a3d18ff1afca6757de5082e08f2313?sample=1
• Huber, C. R., & Kuncel, N. R. (2016). Does college teach critical thinking? A meta-analysis. Review of Educational Research, 86(2), 431-468.
• Kennedy, T. J., & Sundberg, C. W. (2020). 21st century skills. In Science Education in Theory and Practice (pp. 479-496). Springer, Cham.
• Lai, E. R. (2011). Critical thinking: A literature review. Pearson's Research Reports, 6, 40-41.
• Larsson, K. (2021). Using essay responses as a basis for teaching critical thinking–A variation theory approach. Scandinavian Journal of Educational Research, 65(1), 21-35.
• Moon, J. (2007). Critical thinking: An exploration of theory and practice. Routledge.
• Norris, J. M., & Ortega, L. (2000). Effectiveness of L2 instruction: A research synthesis and quantitative meta-analysis. Language Learning, 50, 417–528.
• Nosratinia, M., & Zaker, A. (2014). Metacognitive Attributes and Liberated Progress: The Association Among Second-Language Learners’ Critical Thinking, Creativity, and Autonomy. SAGEOpen, 4(3), 2158244014547178.
• Oracle Education Foundation. (n.d.) Retrieved from (2020, September 10):
http://www.360kid.com/blog/files/Trilling_7cs_21st_Century_Skills.pdf
• Oswald, F. L., & Plonsky, L. (2010). Meta-analysis in second language research: Choices and challenges. Annual Review of Applied Linguistics, 30, 85-110.
• Plonsky, L. (2011). The effectiveness of second language strategy instruction: A meta-analysis. Language learning, 61(4), 9931038.
• Plonsky, L., & Oswald, F. L. (2014). How big is “big”? Interpreting effect sizes in L2 research. Language learning, 64(4), 878-912.
• Richards, J. B., Hayes, M. M., & Schwartzstein, R. M. (2020). Teaching Clinical Reasoning and Critical Thinking: From Cognitive Theory to Practical Application. Chest, 158(4), 1617–1628. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chest.2020.05.525
• Saremi, H., & Bahdori, S. (2015). The relationship between critical thinking with emotional intelligence and creativity among elementary school principals in Bojnord city, Iran. International Journal of Life Sciences, 9(6), 33-40.
• Soodmand Afshar, H., Movassagh, H., & Radi Arbabi, H. (2017). The interrelationship among critical thinking, writing an argumentative essay in an L2 and their subskills. The Language Learning Journal, 45(4), 419-433.
• Taghinezhad, A., Riasati, M. J., Rassaei, E., & Behjat, F. (2018). The Impact of Teaching Critical Thinking on Iranian Students’ Writing Performance and Their Critical Thinking Dispositions. BRAIN. Broad Research in Artificial Intelligence and Neuroscience, 9, 64-80.
• Tajvidi, M., Ghiyasvandian, S., & Salsali, M. (2014). Probing concept of critical thinking in nursing education in Iran: a concept analysis. Asian Nursing Research, 8(2), 158-164.
• Tavakol, & Larijani. (2016). Study of education goals in students' developmental literacy study and ICT facilities in its realization. World Media Magazine-Persian Edition, 11 (2).
• The 7Cs of The 21st century lifelong learning Skills. (2014, May 02). Retrieved from: https://www.educatorstechnology.com/2014/05/the-7cs-of-21st-century-lifelong.html
• Wechsler, S. M., Saiz, C., Rivas, S. F., Vendramini, C. M. M., Almeida, L. S., Mundim, M. C., & Franco, A. (2018). Creative and critical thinking: Independent or overlapping components?. Thinking Skills and Creativity, 27, 114-122.
• Woldt, J. L., & Nenad, M. W. (2021). Reflective writing in dental education to improve critical thinking and learning: A systematic review. Journal of Dental Education, 85(6), 778–785. doi:10.1002/jdd.12561
• Yousefi, A., & Gordanshekan, M. (2012). Critical thinking. Iranian Journal of Medical Education, 11(9 (38 Supplement)), 1120-1128. https://www.sid.ir/en/journal/ViewPaper.aspx?id=257065
• Zangenehvandi, M., Farahian, M., & Gholami, H. (2014). On the relationship between EFL teachers’ criticl thinking and self-efficacy. Modern Journal of Language Teaching Methods, 4(2), 286.

Articles in Press, Accepted Manuscript
Available Online from 13 July 2025